House Speaker Billy McCoy speaks in a halting stutter at times. A stroke shook his frame in 2004. He has recovered to a point, though the scars are still plain. But they donโt slow him down.
Conservative talk radio labels the Rienzi resident as a divisive figure, and pundits say he has not been able to unify the House. Theyโre certainly right about the last part.
McCoy is trying to ride two horses determined to bolt in two different directions, and his situation over the fractious House compares badly to the uniform kingship of the state Senate.
The waters in the Senate are relatively calm, largely because those waters no longer have two different kinds of sharks swimming around in them. Republicans dominate the Senate, even if their technical majority is nonexistent. There are very few liberal-minded Republicans in the Senate, but plenty of conservative-minded Democrats.
Former Lt. Gov. Amy Tuck got comparatively few challenges from riled-up progressives during her time over the Senate, and current Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant is equally likely to have few fights this year regarding his own governor-endorsed agenda.
Back over on the House side, however, the fight is more contentious. In the House, the Republican desire for dominion is not complete, and the two parties are still strong enough to put up a fight with each other as they scratch and jostle for influence.
The clanging swords were obvious last August when the House Republican Conference declared they would be supporting anybody who was not McCoy. House Democrats at the time said they expected Rep. Jeff Smith, D-Columbus, to be on hand at the conference to personally accept the mantle as the Republicansโ replacement for McCoy.
Republicans at first denied any mention of Smith, though Smith declared he was running for the speaker position soon after the Republican conferenceโs announcementโand received strong support from every Republican voting in the speakerโs race this January.
The speaker gets to pick committee heads, and wields considerable influence over what bills end up surviving a particular committee. Thereโs no reason to think the speakerโs screening interviews for committee chairmen isnโt exhaustiveโand no reason to suspect the speaker is unaware of potential chairmenโs views on potential bills prior to those interviews.
Republicans came close to taking the House in the same way they dominate the Senate, by using the Democratsโ wide philosophical umbrella against them. Conservative Democrats like Smith abound in the House, while any Republican voting too many times outside the preferences of Gov. Barbour gets toppled in the primaries. Division and conquest works in most cases, and came close to success this year.
McCoy won a hard victory against Republicans with a two-vote majority, however. It was a turnout that drove him even more deeply into the progressive wing of the Democratic Party, judging by the personalities he selected to chair committees.
The speaker took a definite leap toward new urbanism this year, appointing big-city legislators such as Jackson Reps. Earle Banks and Credell Calhoun to chairs and moving Jackson Reps. Alyce Clark and James Evans to more influential committees.
He retained a Democrat over apportionment and elections, as well as the Congressional Redistricting Committee, a move that will make forming districts unfriendly to Democrats unlikely following the 2010 Census. He also made a point to retain chairmen like Plantersville Democrat Steve Holland over the Public Health and Human Services Committeeโa move that is likely to deliver some Medicaid bills and other health-issue bills that could make the governor look unpopular this year if he fights them.
The speaker, unlike last year, installed no Republicans as chairmen. In this way, he will likely not be able to build upon relationships with members outside a small influential circle. Former Speaker Tim Ford could build alliances across a variety of personalities when it appeared that one particular alliance was not going to pay off. McCoy, perhaps, will not have Fordโs advantage. Of course, some argue that McCoy did not burn his own bridges, that his circle of influence had already caged him in the day House Republicans committed to getting rid of him.
The Jackson Free Press recently spoke with Speaker McCoy.
Have you always been a Democrat?
Iโve never been anything but a Democrat. I grew up in a family that had an all-Democrat background. Iโve always been an old FDR man.
What kept you from switching over to the Republican side during the 1970s through 1990s? Itโs always been a popular move among white Democrats.
It never entered my mind.
So what prevented it from entering your mind?
Democrats have always advocated a philosophy regarding making a difference in peopleโs lives. I grew up in a rural community where rural electrification meant much, and the programs that came along to us, like Social Security, TVA and other programs that meant so much. Democrats provided those programs so even farmers and the those who have little influence could have an opportunity to succeed. Thatโs the kind of thing that made so much difference to me, and itโs a philosophy that I follow to this day.
Your first run for speaker was also your first successful run for speaker, right?
Yes, I ran four years ago for speaker. Iโve been elected nine times by the people of Prentiss and Alcorn counties to be their voice in the Mississippi House and two times by the members of the House to be the speaker.
What drove you to want to be speaker? Obviously the job comes with a series of ailments.
It gives a greater opportunity for one person to represent the people at the very highest level. Iโve worked with many members of the House since 1980. I watched the speakerโs position for all these years, and helped other speakers succeed, so when the opportunity looked like it was going to arise, many members came to me and asked me to consider running. I wouldnโt have done it if I hadnโt had their support four years ago, and I wouldnโt have run this time if I hadnโt had their support.
What was the atmosphere in the House four years ago? What kind of issues were cooking?
Ultimately, itโs always been about how we spend the taxpayersโ money. Itโs always about trying to have quality education, and trying to provide health care for those who cannot provide for themselves, especially the disabled and children. And it has always been about having a quality transportation system in the state, about backing our law enforcement officers and our firemen. And, just like now, itโs been about doing everything you can do to provide quality jobs for Mississippi.
Your position is not term-limited, but Iโve heard some House members speaking of this term of yours as some kind of legacy term. Is that the reality of it?
Weโve always had long-range plans and short-range plans, and they still involve making a difference in the five or six basic areas that government needs to focus on: education; public health; protection of life and property; economic development; and transportation.
Iโve heard (Rep.) Percy Watson and some others saying House members will be focusing on trying to get out the (grocery/cigarette) tax swap bill again this year. Do you personally see those two taxes rolled into the same bill again, or could they each be on separate bills this year?
The governor said weโll have a study plan to look at the tax structure of the state. Heโs already appointed the committee to begin looking at the tax structure. Of course, the House has always had an ongoing effort to adjust the tax structure of the state. Our grocery tax and cigarette tax swap were a part of that. It made sense. We can wait for the big master plan, but when it gets here, itโll probably be cut all to pieces by smaller issues that weโve been talking about. But I would say that cutting the tax on groceries is high on our agenda.
The governor disagrees about the need for decreasing the grocery tax. I believe heโd said, โEverybody needs to pay some kind of tax,โ referring to the grocery tax.
Yeah, I read that. Everybody already pays some kind of tax. He can cut the tax on groceries, and everybody will still be paying some kind of tax when they go to the gas station, when they check into a hotel. Any place they go, theyโll already be paying some kind of tax. He wants them to keep paying the high grocery tax, in addition to those other taxes, and he wants them to pay a new tax by taxing a hospital bed, which is reprehensible to me.
I assume you believe that a hospital tax will gravitate down to the patient?
The very next day. It will travel down to them the very next day. Theyโll get hit with it right in their face while theyโre laying flat on their backs.
What can the House do about the Medicaid shortfall this year? Will the House have to concede to cuts in Medicaid this year if the shortfall is insurmountable?
The House is committed to the state providing the very same services it is already providing through Medicaid. We have several weeks to work on this, and weโll hopefully accomplish this.
The money would have to come from somewhere else inside the budget if the state doesnโt increase revenue. Is there any other budget money that you can envision going into Medicaid?
I wouldnโt want to speculate on that. When we get down to the priorities of the budget, everything is subject to being dealt with on a priority basis.

Representatives like Republican Bill Denny (of Jackson) describe you as beyond the mainstream, as if Republicans and conservative Democrats are the real moderates in Mississippi? Do you ever have doubts that maybe you are out of touch with a large percentage of the state?
Not even for a minute. Iโve been elected nine times, and elected twice as speaker. Re-election doesnโt happen to somebody whoโs out of touch with the people he represents. The precepts and principles by which I believe in government have been on view every day. I donโt hide them from anybody, and I still get re-elected.
Conservative Democrats and their Republican allies seem to make up almost half the House these days. Is there a chance that Denny and his friends have a point? Do you think those guys represent the real face of Mississippi?
Iโm not going to comment on that. I know that I represent the real face of Mississippi. You canโt be a representative since 1980 and be out of touch.
Describe the partisanship that currently divides the House. Did it really start with Barbour, or was it growing before he came along?
Itโs always been here to a point. Thatโs just government. But Barbour came down from Washington and brought it to a new high. Itโs been in Washington a long time at a hurtful level. Now itโs come to Mississippi, in as hurtful a level as it is in Washington, and Iโd say itโs moving on down to city and county government on a hurtful level. We should not be in any situation because of political party. People should have different views that arenโt dictated by any political party.
How has the emerging hostility in the House affected progress?
Many bills get affected by it, but things still get along. The transportation and highway program bills have not often been such a problem, but youโd think public education bills wouldnโt have met the problems they faced because of the good things they do. Economic development bills like Advantage Mississippi, under Gov. Musgrove and Momentum Mississippi under Barbourโboth of which serve to attract major business and industry to the stateโweโve joined together to pass these kinds of bills. Weโre there (working together) every week, and weโll be there every week.
So while you call the partisanship hurtful, you donโt feel it is shutting down the House at this point?
Not at all. Not at all.
What do you plan to do this year to aid the situation? What are you doing to forge ties?
Weโre going to pass bills in the House that we feel should be the goal of every Mississippian. Naturally, there will be differences, but you will see some very notable legislation in each of these major areas that we spoke of earlier, health care and education and so forth. We should be working together because these bills will so obviously make a difference to the people of Mississippi, whether theyโre in Gulfport, Jackson, the Delta or anywhere. The unity should, rightfully, be there on many of these bills, despite the growing partisanship.
Hah. Chunky chance of that one, buddy. Were you surprised when the Republican coalition proclaimed they were going to remove you last November?
They voted to vote for anybody but me. I canโt say it surprised me. Nothing surprises me in politics or in raising corn anymore.
They claim youโve ignored the issues of conservatives. Can you deny that you actively worked to kill tort reform when it raised its head in the regular session?
All major issues have been considered and voted on by House members, all major issues.

But the most recent tort reform had to be settled in a special session.
And during that special session, it still went through the committee process and was addressed by the House. The system still worked.
Conservatives make it sound as if youโve had an active role in killing conservative bills.
Any speaker has a great deal of influence over legislation, but we still use the committee system. Bills are heard, and these issues are always dealt with by the committee and then by the body of the House.
Letโs use voter ID as a quick example from last year. Voter ID came up. Republicans championed it; many Democrats opposed it. The effort died last year. You were speaker. Coincidence?
Voter ID was considered by committee, and a majority of the House addressed the bill and voted how they voted on it. Weโve passed voter ID bills. Just because it didnโt come out as a particular person or group or faction wants doesnโt mean democracy hasnโt prevailed and the issue wasnโt addressed. The committees and House members did (their) job.
Letโs speak on those committees. A lot of chairmanships this year went not only to Democrats, but considerably progressive Democrats. Whatโs your strategy there?
It wasnโt a strategy. My purpose was to appoint the best people in their particular positions, and I think I picked the best individuals to serve those particular committees. I based the choices on a lot of things: their tenure, their interest in the subject, their ability to get legislation passed and so forth.
Yeah, but it seems like these particular chairs are not in accord with many of Barbourโs beliefs. Iโd even predict that the kind of bills these guys let out of committee are going to be thorns in Barbourโs hide.
Well, that was not the purpose of appointing them. Our purpose is to pass legislation that will make a difference to the people of this state, to appropriate funds and pass major bond issues that will make a difference and use the taxpayersโ money wisely.
I assume there are some bills or issues that you feel these progressive chairs would be more equipped to handle, right?
Maybe youโre putting words in my mouth. Let me just say that I feel our chairmen will move forward in a very progressive way to use the resources and revenue that this state has been given to spend in the very best manner. Thatโs the purpose.
I see more Jackson Democrats in chairmanships this year. Credell Calhoun is one example. Whatโs your motivation in that? What will Jackson Democrats do for the House?
We try very hard not to make decisions based on cities or regions. The choices I made were based on tenure, ability and individualsโ desire. There are probably 10 or 15 individuals who could have ably filled any of those positions. It was not an easy choice. But we do want to do all we can to help our state capital be the very best it can be, and weโre working with the city leaders and the representatives of the people of Jackson to have a very fine and model capital city.
I also couldnโt help noticing that no chairmanships feature a Republican. Is that your gratitude for being so openly opposed by the Republican coalition? Were you listening to Rep. Steve Hollandโs middle finger or was that an accident?
My answer has been and has to remain that the chairmanships speak for themselves.
Can you say then that it was less about hurting Republicans and more about putting the right people in charge?
The chairmanships speak for themselves.
Well, to a point, I suppose. Something Iโve been meaning to ask you: How did you guys bring around Rep. Linda Coleman, D-Mound Bayou, in the speaker vote? I hear Democrats knew she wasnโt initially favoring you and may have marched some of her heroes before her to bring her around in the days leading up to the vote. I also noticed the Mississippi NAACP president sitting very close to Rep. Chuck Espy, D-Clarksdale, on the day of the vote.
Rep. Coleman, like all representatives, will have to speak for (herself). Itโs not my place to do that.
I notice sheโs chairman over Fees and Salaries of Public Officers now. Is there any connection between that and her vote?
Rep. Coleman is a super representative who will make a great chairman. Sheโs also a very independent person. Nobody tells her what to do by way of her computer.
Which Iโve heard is a common way for votes to get around in the House these days. Is it true that the governorโs people tell certain representatives how to vote through e-mail?
They do seem to speak with a very unified voice, is all I know. I know a lot more than that, but Iโm not speaking on that. I would rather you ask them yourself.
I was talking to former Republican Rep. Clint Rotenberry a few months ago. He told me how he fell out of favor with Barbour on a vote or two, and that he believed the party turned on him and recruited another Republican to unseat him in the primary. Heโs gone now. Any comment?
None at all.
I notice the oath of office this year contains a promise not to let your vote fall under the influence of another elected official.
Everybody sort of chuckles about that, donโt they? That oath has been there for as long as I can remember.
Can you say that Democrats exert no influence over each other in such a manner?
Thatโs a good question. Naturally we correspond with members when weโre up against a major issue, but we donโt put any pressure on anybody. We just talk to them. We talk to Republicans, too. Thatโs what weโve always done. Thereโs no pressure that I can exert on Democratic votes.
How has the close speaker race affected you since then? Iโve spoken to Espy, who said he was willing to throw his backing behind Rep. Jeff Smith in the speakerโs race because he felt the Democratic leadership had put the Delta region on the back burner. What steps have you made to encourage some form of solidarity between House leadership and people like Espy?
We continue to talk. We speak on every major issue, and weโre learning in each discussion of more things that we need to be considerate of.
So has there been a new growth of empathy for the Delta region since the election?
Weโve always worked to make a difference in the Delta, ever since I was elected to the Legislature, and we will continue to do that. We have an outstanding delegation from the Delta who constantly works hard to make a difference there. The same goes for every region of the state, but the Delta has a group of representatives who are dedicated to making a difference not only to their districts, but also to their area as a whole. Weโre finding that theyโre becoming more united in their efforts to better the region. Thatโs good. It should get the delegation far in the House.
Previous Comments
Adam did a great job with this interview, but after reading it I can’t escape the feeling that McCoy has a very effective brick wall that’s very hard to penetrate. I wouldn’t want to play high-stakes poker with this guy!
#82201 | Author: Tom Head | Date: Jan 30 2008
Thanks Adam. Excellent job. Thank God for McCoy. Mississippi needs real giants.
#82202 | Author: Ray Carter | Date: Jan 31 2008
Ater all, you don’t successfully fight off snakes, lions and bears in the wilderness then upon finding shelter and safety inside a barricade or fortress then leave the door open so that the same devouring forces can easily come into your safe zone and harm you. People think Democrats are dumb!
#82203 | Author: Ray Carter | Date: Jan 31 2008
Hah. Chunky chance of that one, buddy. Only Adam Lynch could get away with that line in an interview. ๐
#82204 | Author: LatashaWillis | Date: Feb 2 2008
Really do not know where to post this, but the Sun-Herald is reporting that Rep. Compretta’s son was killed in an accident in New Orleans while participating in a parade.
#82205 | Author: ChrisCavanaugh | Date: Feb 3 2008



