Jackson Free Press logo

This story originally appeared in the Jackson Free Press. It was added to the Mississippi Free Press website in 2025.
Note that any opinions expressed in legacy Jackson Free Press stories do not reflect a position of the Mississippi Free Press or necessarily of its staff and board members.

As a physician and ex-smoker (four packs a day, clean for 20 years), Iโ€™m an advocate of helping smokers quit. I know the terrible health consequences of smoking. However, I am befuddled by your recent decision to poke a stick into the eye of Gov. Barbour with your tobacco/food tax legislation which, as you know, is not revenue neutral.

As you are well aware, the Republican Party took you in when you had no shelter in the storm. It was revealed at that time that you were beholden to Richard Scruggs for an โ€œunpaid loanโ€ (an unpaid gift in politics amounts to what?โ€”a โ€œbribe,โ€ a โ€œpayoff?โ€) of $500,000. The GOP paid this โ€œloanโ€ off for you because it was so โ€œunseemly.โ€

It appears that the only explanation for your decision to move against Gov. Barbour is that the House members who represent the Northeastern portion of the state and/or your old and continuing association with Mr. Scruggs and Mr. Michael Moore (arenโ€™t you still a board member of The Partnership for a Healthy Mississippiโ€”or is it The Boys and Girls Clubs of Mississippi?โ€”their Web sites do not list board members), and your association with โ€œfolksโ€ from the Northern part of this state have some aspect of your past or future career under their thumb. What is that? Why do they have you under their thumb?โ€”is it political, financialโ€”what is it? What have they promised you?

But more importantly, it is obvious that you have another agenda regarding your own political future, and it obviously doesnโ€™t include remaining a member of the Republican Party of Mississippi. With this type of behavior, you will be unable to run for governor of this State, or for the congressional seat in Rep. Pickeringโ€™s district (should he run for a national Senate seat) as a Republican. We (lowly Republican voters) will not support you if you become or remain Governor Barbourโ€™s nemesis. I assume that you think that your future is (somehow) associated with Michael Moore and Richard Scruggs and politicians of northeast Mississippi. Well, good luck with them. They have the money to buy you whatever you want. However, youโ€™ll have to return to the Democrat fold. (What! Another change in party affiliation?) I doubt those โ€œyellow dog democratsโ€ will appreciate another โ€œabout face.โ€

I beg you to reconsider your position regarding the tobacco/tax. You know this โ€œtaxโ€ will only drive tobacco sales to contiguous states, or the Internet, or Native American stores, and decimate small communitiesโ€™ reliance on local sales taxes. The response to this loss in local sales tax (and Iโ€™ll never believe that decreasing tobacco sales will โ€œmake up the differenceโ€) will be a rise in other local taxes, especially property taxes (i.e. a โ€œtax shift.โ€)

I suggest that if you remain steadfast on this path Republicans in this state will drop you like a โ€œhot potato.โ€ We lowly Republican voters will do all we can to unseat you and all your allies if you continue your adversarial relationship with our beloved Gov. Barbour. You owe, and we demand, an accounting of your recent behavior to Republicans who supported your โ€œslideโ€ to our party. Why have you put Gov. Barbour and the Republicans of this state in such a pickle?
โ€” HD Matthias, Madison

Previous Comments

Advice for the day: People who sign petitions against the Estate Tax (which would primarily benefit multi-millionaires, and cost the government $30 billion per year) should not then complain about the purported irresponsibility of supporting arguably revenue-neutral tax cuts that would benefit the poor. I mean, seriously. Do people even pretend to be intellectually honest about this stuff anymore? Cheers, TH


No.

Mississippi native Donna Ladd and partner Todd Stauffer founded the Jackson Free Press in 2002 in the capital city. The heavily awarded local newspaper did many investigations heralded across the state and nation and served as a paper of record due to its diversity, inclusion, in-depth reporting and deep connection to readers and dedication to narrative change in and about Mississippi. In 2022, the nonprofit Mississippi Free Press, founded by Ladd and JFP Associate Publisher Kimberly Griffin in 2020, purchased the journalism assets and archives of the Jackson Free Press. A Google grant through AAN Publishers enabled Newspack's integration of the JFP archives into the Mississippi Free Press website to become part of a more searchable archive of recent Mississippi history and essential journalism.