Jackson Free Press logo

This story originally appeared in the Jackson Free Press. It was added to the Mississippi Free Press website in 2025.
Note that any opinions expressed in legacy Jackson Free Press stories do not reflect a position of the Mississippi Free Press or necessarily of its staff and board members.

As the full truth of the cityโ€™s considerable budget crisis has emerged, one additional thing about Mayor Frank Melton has come into full reliefโ€”heโ€™s doesnโ€™t know how to run the city. Couple this with the crime statistics that show Melton doesnโ€™t know how to run a police department, and weโ€™re forced to recognize thatโ€”aside from speaking to TV cameras and trashing other public officialsโ€”thereโ€™s very little that Mr. Melton actually can do.

Unfortunately, the professionals that Melton has surrounded himself with have also failed to step up and lead. Police Chief Shirlene Anderson is just a weak proxy for Meltonโ€”this we already know. City Administrator Robert Walkerโ€™s recent fumblings in City Council work sessions, where he seems unwilling or unable to answer basic questions about budget-line items, revenue sources and contract workers, suggests that heโ€™s not the cleaner for Meltonโ€™s spills.

Short of Mr. Melton stepping down from office and the city holding a special electionโ€”which the Jackson Free Press would fully support at this timeโ€”itโ€™s time to get some outside help:

1. An external audit. The city should contract with a competent audit firm to answer the City Councilโ€™s questions about revenue streams and the budget. Clearly, the Melton administration is grossly underestimating revenues and expenditures. It also appears that the city is unable or unwilling to account for hundreds of thousands of dollars in payments to temporary workers, some of which are clearly going to Meltonโ€™s โ€œkidsโ€ and others whose job titles donโ€™t fit their duties. We deserve to know how Mr. Melton is spending our money.

2. A city manager search. If Mr. Melton is going to remain as the figurehead mayor, itโ€™s time for him to do everything he can to bring in and empower a โ€œCEOโ€ for the city. Melton has already said โ€œhe doesnโ€™t run the cityโ€ and heโ€™s not a โ€œfinancial guy.โ€ He needs to find that person and then let that person do his or her job.

3. A police chief search. The โ€œcook the booksโ€ charge is getting old. You canโ€™t cook the books on murderโ€”which is way upโ€”and you canโ€™t cook the books on the fact that JPD didnโ€™t make a single intent-to-distribute arrest in 2006. Mayor Melton trumpeted the election of incoming Hinds D.A. Robert Smith by saying โ€œI thank God tonight that I have somebody who will put these drug dealers in jail.โ€ What he needs is a police chief who will arrest the drug dealers in the first place. (Hint: Watch what that Mayor does and not just what he says.)

Weโ€™d prefer to see the mayor step down. But failing that, Jacksonโ€™s next step is for citizens and stakeholders to demand the mayor inject some accountability into his administration. We must insist that he put professionals in place in the cityโ€™s core service areasโ€”and then get out of their way.

Previous Comments

I like the list. If the administration were to follow it, this city would end up in much better shape over the next couple of years, and I would give Melton credit for doing something right.


I like the list also, but I don’t think it is feasible with the current administration. Melton knows he can’t run the city (other than into the ground) and he still won’t admit it. He seems to enjoy the power trip of being mayor. He will not hire anyone with a backbone. If he hired a police chief that would do their job and not be a doormat for him, he couldn’t possibly get away with taking over the Mobile Command Unit at will and assigning officers where he wants them. Shirlene made the statement that the protection offered to Smith would be the same as for any citizen threatened. Hell, Shirlene, we all feel threatened! Haven’t you heard……CRIME IS UP!!!

Mississippi native Donna Ladd and partner Todd Stauffer founded the Jackson Free Press in 2002 in the capital city. The heavily awarded local newspaper did many investigations heralded across the state and nation and served as a paper of record due to its diversity, inclusion, in-depth reporting and deep connection to readers and dedication to narrative change in and about Mississippi. In 2022, the nonprofit Mississippi Free Press, founded by Ladd and JFP Associate Publisher Kimberly Griffin in 2020, purchased the journalism assets and archives of the Jackson Free Press. A Google grant through AAN Publishers enabled Newspack's integration of the JFP archives into the Mississippi Free Press website to become part of a more searchable archive of recent Mississippi history and essential journalism.