Jackson Free Press logo

This story originally appeared in the Jackson Free Press. It was added to the Mississippi Free Press website in 2025.
Note that any opinions expressed in legacy Jackson Free Press stories do not reflect a position of the Mississippi Free Press or necessarily of its staff and board members.

… is that sometimes it isn’t true. Read what a political science professor has to say about Frank Melton’s antics on his blog:

Meanwhile, a follow-up to a post I made to this site over the summer: Frank Melton, the Nancy Grace-with-official-government-power-ish mayor of Jackson MS–and like Nancy, a former TV celeb (only at the local level, but …) who has practically zero respect for the American justice system and the Constitution. Frank, as anyone outside of his cult could have predicted, has been indicted, in this case on charges of burglary and malicious mischief, etc., in connection with the unathorized demolition of a Jackson duplex. The Melton story, it appears, is like “Network” meeting the real world of public policy, at the grass roots level. It’s horrible.

And while I’m sure readers from elsewhere might think, Well, look where he was, Melton was not a native of the city or state. And what people loved about him was the straight talking bit that too many people think equals “honest person.”

As noted here before, the Zen Buddhists were (or rather, are) onto something in seeing the limits of language, something thoughtful people can’t help but notice in the era of hyper-PR. What is not as often thought, however, is that laconic speakers, or straight talkers, can be just as misleading as the hopelessly verbose. Mix TV imagery, immediacy and simplification of complex issues in with the built-in limits of language, in a city with a serious crime problem (and, certainly, a thorny racial and political history, although I don’t think it’s at all the most important variable here), and you end up with a Frank Melton.

Previous Comments

The use of the word “cult” is intriguingly accurate, eh? That’s certainly what Melton apologists act like.


Cult is very telling, indeed.


One of the key features of a cult, according to a book I read many years ago, was the need/desire to be cut off from the rest of society. This prevents outside ideas from coming in and contaminating the brains of the devotees. Seems to me in this case, it’s true. But it’s a willful separation from facts/reality, rather than a simple physical removal from society (Jonestown, Waco compound, etc.). Takes a real mental effort to continue to believe in Melton, after all that’s come down. I also really like that he points out the fallacy inherent in the notion that “straigth talk” = honesty.

Founding Editor Donna Ladd is a writer, journalist and editor from Philadelphia, Miss., a graduate of Mississippi State University and later the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, where she was an alumni award recipient in 2021. She writes about racism/whiteness, poverty, gender, violence, journalism and the criminal justice system. She contributes long-form features and essays to The Guardian when she has time, and was the co-founder and editor-in-chief of the Jackson Free Press. She co-founded the statewide nonprofit Mississippi Free Press with Kimberly Griffin in March 2020, and the Mississippi Business Journal named her one of the state's top CEOs in 2024. Read more at donnaladd.com, follow her on Twitter and Instagram at @donnerkay and email her at donna@mississippifreepress.org.