Jackson Free Press logo

This story originally appeared in the Jackson Free Press. It was added to the Mississippi Free Press website in 2025.
Note that any opinions expressed in legacy Jackson Free Press stories do not reflect a position of the Mississippi Free Press or necessarily of its staff and board members.

Former mayoral bodyguards Michael Recio, pictured, and Marcus Wright are challenging court-ordered restitution. Credit: File Photo

Cynthia Stewart, attorney for Michael Recio, has subpoenaed Jackson City Attorney Sarah O’Reilly-Evans in the civil rights trial of Recio and mayor Frank Melton.

The subpoena (PDF) asks O’Reilly-Evans to bring to trial on Jan. 5 all documents related to the termination of deputy city attorney Katherine Pugh and any JPD Internal Affairs files that federal prosecutors may have requested. Pugh’s last day with the city attorney’s office was Tuesday, Nov. 11. Last week JPD Chief and Hinds County Sheriff Malcolm McMillin rehired Pugh as an attorney for the Hinds County Sheriff’s Department.

The staff shuffle came on the heels of a provocative motion filed jointly by Melton and Recio alleging that prosecutors had concealed the existence of an Internal Affairs file on former mayoral bodyguard Marcus Wright, who is cooperating with the prosecution. The file, which prosecutors eventually provided to the defense, concerns allegations by a former male prostitute that Wright engaged in sexual misconduct while on duty.

Full Melton coverage/archive here.
PDFs of all U.S. v. Melton documents
View photos of Ridgeway Street duplex destruction.
Read Adam Lynch’s story that started it all.

MFP Solutions Lab logo

The Mississippi Free Press produced this story through the MFP Solutions Lab, supported by the Solutions Journalism Network. This series digs into Mississippi’s systemic issues and sheds light on responses to them in other communities. Beyond just reporting on problems, these stories interrogate their causes and inspect potential solutions.