Jackson Free Press logo

This story originally appeared in the Jackson Free Press. It was added to the Mississippi Free Press website in 2025.
Note that any opinions expressed in legacy Jackson Free Press stories do not reflect a position of the Mississippi Free Press or necessarily of its staff and board members.

Patsy Brumsfield is reporting on the deal-or-no-deal confusion at The Daily Journal. (Hat tip to Folo.):

Now, the talk – by sources close to the case – centers on former Hinds District Attorney Ed Peters, DeLaughter’s former boss, who reportedly has crucial information for prosecutors, if he decides to cooperate.

In a January guilty plea, former Booneville attorney Joey Langston admitted under oath that Peters was a key actor in carrying information back and forth between Scruggs and DeLaughter in Scruggs’ alleged efforts to make sure the judge ruled in his favor in the lawsuit Wilson v. Scruggs. Roberts Wilson, then a Jackson attorney, sued Scruggs for a larger share of legal fees he said he was owed from nationwide asbestos cases.

DeLaughter insists he has done nothing wrong, but he was suspended indefinitely from the bench while the Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance investigates allegations of improper conduct related to his rulings.

Plea deal a holdup?
Insiders say the current federal investigators may be trying to work out a plea deal acceptable to Peters and to the U.S. Department of Justice’s Public Integrity Division, which also has come into the case.

Sources say the U.S. Attorney’s Office may have offered Peters a deal, which the Department of Justice later disapproved when it received more allegations of wrongdoing between Peters and DeLaughter.

My guess is that Ed Peters has been privy to all sorts of tidbits the feds could be interested in. Just a guess. But let’s hope that, if he did offer a million-dollar bribe, that he doesn’t walk free. Not sure that would qualify as justice.

Previous Comments

My Mom might end up right yet; She’s never like the guy and claimed they “have to screw him in the ground to bury him.” Sad that so many normal citizens have been blinded to the reality of their government.


I hope it’s a deal that gives him a new home for years. These people would be thrown under the jail too just as a crack cocaine seller is if the criminal justice system was fair to everyone. The slaps on the wrist with 1-5 years does nothing to deter these types of criminals.

Founding Editor Donna Ladd is a writer, journalist and editor from Philadelphia, Miss., a graduate of Mississippi State University and later the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, where she was an alumni award recipient in 2021. She writes about racism/whiteness, poverty, gender, violence, journalism and the criminal justice system. She contributes long-form features and essays to The Guardian when she has time, and was the co-founder and editor-in-chief of the Jackson Free Press. She co-founded the statewide nonprofit Mississippi Free Press with Kimberly Griffin in March 2020, and the Mississippi Business Journal named her one of the state's top CEOs in 2024. Read more at donnaladd.com, follow her on Twitter and Instagram at @donnerkay and email her at donna@mississippifreepress.org.